Going on strike usually means giving up your paycheck for work not performed. Harvard says that principle applies to its graduate student workers. In practice, it hasn’t.

According to the Harvard Graduate Students Union (HGSU), Harvard has always paid striking workers for work they didn’t do in the union’s past strikes. That appears to be the case again now. That’s because the Harvard administration uses a reporting system that depends on strikers identifying themselves, which the union has told its members not to do.

One fix could be flipping the question: instead of asking graduate student workers to report work they haven’t done, Harvard could ask all of them to confirm the work they have.

HGSU, which represents more than 4,000 graduate student workers, including the teaching fellows (TFs) who lead undergraduate discussion sections for lectures, is on its fourth strike in seven years.

So why has Harvard repeatedly failed to withhold pay? The problem lies in how graduate student work is supervised and currently reported. Graduate student workers report to the faculty members they teach or conduct research for, and Harvard has relied on graduate students or their faculty supervisors to disclose if the student is withholding work. In 2019, for example, Harvard asked departments to identify striking TFs. Some departments did, while others refused.

Since then — in the strikes of fall 2021, spring 2026, and currently — Harvard has relied on workers to report withheld labor themselves. During the spring 2026 strike, Harvard introduced an online attestation system, but HGSU told members not to fill it out. The union says Harvard identified fewer than 20 strikers and withheld pay from none — during a strike that drew hundreds of workers on the picket line, according to The Crimson. 

This system creates backwards incentives. Two workers could withhold the same amount of labor, yet only the one who reports it might lose pay. Enforcing the rule selectively would effectively penalize honesty. Faculty face a similar dilemma: when some professors or departments refuse Harvard’s request to identify striking workers, those who follow the policy and cooperate can appear to be taking sides rather than carrying out a shared University payroll requirement. 

Graduate student workers, like other unionized employees, have the right to strike — but not to be paid for the work they don’t do, a distinction that HGSU itself acknowledges. A strike is meant to be costly to both sides — one in terms of lost labor and one in terms of lost pay — and the shared cost is part of what moves both toward an agreement. 

As one instructor considering striking wrote in a Crimson op-ed, striking while continuing to be paid by Harvard his usual salary of effectively “more than $60 per hour” would be “incompatible with the standard purpose and function of a strike.” 

In that instructor’s case, the prospect of giving up wages for work he doesn’t do feels real because he’s a member of Harvard Academic Workers (HAW), not HGSU, since he’s not currently a grad student. Due to the format of work and administrative oversight of HAW’s roughly 2,600 non-tenure-track faculty (NTTs), researchers, and postdocs, it’s easier for Harvard to pay only HAW workers who are working. With HAW members now striking too, Harvard’s ability to apply its pay policy consistently matters beyond one bargaining unit. 

Harvard could fix this with a change to its existing reporting system. For example, instead of asking workers to report labor they’ve withheld, it could flip the process:

  • All graduate student workers would confirm the work they’ve performed, whether or not they’re striking.

  • Those who don’t respond would be presumed to have withheld work — rather than continuing to receive pay by default (with reports subject to verification and an opportunity to correct the record).

HGSU may still oppose a system that makes pay deductions for striking workers more likely. But Harvard can make those decisions based on whether work was actually performed, rather than workers’ willingness to identify themselves as striking. Other universities have used this approach, including UC Irvine, which previously struggled with similar problems applying their pay policies, and Columbia. 

Harvard’s administration can’t make enforcement of its own pay policy depend on HGSU’s willingness to cooperate with its reporting requirements. Harvard needs a system that respects workers’ right to strike while ensuring that those who perform their duties are paid, and those who withhold labor aren’t paid for work they don’t do. After four strikes, the reporting problem isn’t a surprise. It’s something Harvard has the experience and tools to address.

Ask 1636

Send us your Harvard and higher education questions!

Q: As Harvard considers establishing a University-wide faculty senate, do its peers have similar structures?

Several of Harvard’s peers have established faculty senates, though their membership and authority vary considerably.

  • University-wide faculty senates: Cornell, Penn, and Stanford have elected faculty senates, but their powers differ. Stanford’s and Cornell’s have formal academic policymaking authority, while Penn’s is primarily advisory, though its elected executive committee can approve certain policy changes in areas such as faculty employment, academic freedom, and educational policy.

  • Senates with different constituencies: Yale has an advisory-only faculty senate representing its Faculty of Arts and Sciences and School of Engineering and Applied Science. Columbia has a 111-member University Senate that includes faculty (who hold a majority of seats), students, administrators, researchers, and other constituencies. Its senate has formal authority over certain degree requirements and University-wide conduct rules, subject to trustee oversight.

Events

  • New York, NY — November 18 at 6:30 p.m. ET: Columbia Law School professors Joshua Mitts and David Pozen will debate whether universities should be governed by their campus communities or independent boards, and what each approach means for academic freedom, accountability, and institutional independence. Register here.

  • Boston, MA — December 5 from 8:30 a.m.-3:30 p.m. ET: The Harvard Club of Boston is hosting Harvard’s 46th Saturday of Symposia, featuring School of Engineering and Applied Sciences Dean David Parkes and talks from Harvard faculty members conducting research across a range of fields. Register here.

FYIs

Harvard Academic Workers Begin First Strike
  • Harvard Academic Workers-UAW (HAW-UAW), representing approximately 2,600 non-tenure-track (NTT) faculty, researchers, and postdocs, began its first strike on November 10 after more than two years of contract negotiations. Outstanding disputes include wages, family benefits, union dues, and whether stipend-funded postdoctoral fellows should be included in the bargaining unit.

  • The strike impacts dozens of undergraduate courses where NTTs often serve as lead instructors, including Expository Writing (the mandatory first-year writing course), language, and introductory math classes.

  • In an interview with The Crimson, College Dean David Deming (PhD ‘10) said that Harvard hadn’t developed extensive contingency plans before the strike because “that would sort of be inconsistent with the idea that parties are negotiating in good faith.” He acknowledged maintaining academic continuity would be “really hard” and described his approach as “react mode” because he isn’t directly involved in negotiations.

  • Contract negotiations are handled by Harvard HR’s Office of Labor and Employee Relations, which reports through the central administration under EVP Meredith Weenick (AB ‘90, MBA ‘02). FAS administration, rather than the College, ultimately oversees payroll.

  • HAW-UAW is the second Harvard union to strike this fall, following the Harvard Graduate Students Union (HGSU), which began its strike on October 27. Harvard’s dining services workers (HUDS) have also authorized a strike but haven’t announced a date.

HLS Suspends Students’ Library Access After Pro-Union “Study-In”
  • Harvard Law School (HLS) suspended at least 18 students’ access to Langdell Library for two weeks following a November 6 “study-in” supporting clinical instructors represented by HAW. Roughly 40 students participated in the silent protest, displaying signs on their laptops calling for changes to pay.

  • HLS said the coordinated display of signs constituted an organized demonstration in violation of library rules prohibiting protests, which it also enforced during similar protests in 2024. In a 2024 essay, University Librarian Martha Whitehead argued that even silent protests can disrupt libraries because “an assembly of people displaying signs changes a reading room from a place for individual learning and reflection to a forum for public statements.”

  • HLS professor Stephen Sachs (AB ‘02) supported the suspensions, pointing to similar penalties imposed on students following 2024 study-ins connected to the Israel-Palestine conflict. “The Law School should treat all its students fairly and enforce its library policies evenly, without regard to the students’ cause,” he said. Students can appeal the suspensions, which won’t appear on their disciplinary records.

Harvard Still Without Permanent Middle Eastern Studies Director; Two Faculty Turn Down Role
  • More than 18 months after Harvard removed the leadership of its Center for Middle Eastern Studies (CMES), The Crimson reports that at least two professors have declined offers to lead the center. Interim director Salmaan Keshavjee has had his appointment extended four times and is now set to serve through June 2027.

  • In March 2025, Dean of Social Science David Cutler removed CMES director Cemal Kafadar and associate director Rosie Bsheer. Under Kafadar and Bsheer’s leadership, CMES was regularly criticized for its “blatantly one-sided framing” of topics around Israel-Palestine. FAS Dean Hopi Hoekstra defended the leadership change as necessary to ensure effective management and commitment to intellectual diversity.

  • An FAS spokesperson said the search is ongoing because “the faculty director helps shape the center’s intellectual direction, and the Dean of Social Science is taking the time necessary to find the next leader.”

May Mailman Returns to White House in Temporary Role
  • May Mailman (JD ‘15), a former senior White House policy strategist who played a central role in the federal government’s 2025 confrontation with Harvard, is returning temporarily to help newly appointed chief of staff Stephen Miller with staffing and operations.

  • In her previous White House role, Mailman helped architect the government’s efforts to reshape higher education, including its attempt to bar Harvard from enrolling international students, and led settlement negotiations with Harvard and other universities.

  • Mailman left the administration in August 2025 to establish a lobbying firm. She is returning as a special government employee for several weeks, reportedly without a policy role.

More News

More News at Harvard
  • Wall Street Journal: “The Reading List for the Hottest Class at Harvard” — feat. College course Humanities 10

  • Boston Globe: “‘We’re Not Asking for the Moon’: Harvard Strike Grows as Academic Workers Walk Out”

  • The Crimson: “Harvard Students Struggle With Loss of Academic Support Amid Graduate Student Strike”

  • The Crimson: “Harvard Law Postpones Ames Moot Court Rounds to Spring, Citing Graduate Student Union Strike”

  • The Crimson: “Harvard Law School Students Stage Library ‘Study-In’ in Support of Clinical Instructors”

  • Washington Free Beacon: “Harvard Strike Escalates With Library Protest as Socialists, Foreigners Force Classes to Halt”

  • The Harvard Law Record: “Is Your Speaker Controversial? HLS Wants to Know — and May Send the Bill”

  • The Context Window: “Does A.I. Make You a Better Writer? What the Research Says” — feat. David Deming (PhD ‘10), dean of Harvard College and economics professor at FAS, Harvard Kennedy School, and Harvard Graduate School of Education

  • The Crimson: “Harvard Plans $21 Million in Renovations to Longwood Buildings”

  • The Crimson: “PBHA Volunteer Enrollment Spikes to Highest Number Since Covid-19”

  • Econ Journal Watch: “After SFFA v. Harvard: Predictions That Didn’t Come True”

  • The Crimson: “Harvard Innovation Labs Calls for Students to Address the ‘Unprompted’ in President’s Innovation Challenge Launch”

  • Harvard Gazette: “Helping Vets, Other Public Servants Take Next Step in Leadership”

  • The Harvard Law Record: “Meet Ifeanyi and Tenzin, the 2Ls Leading Student Government”

  • The Crimson: “Deming Says Future of Phillips Brooks House Faculty Director Position Remains Uncertain” — feat. David Deming (PhD ‘10), dean of Harvard College

  • Harvard Medical School: “Getting to Know New Ombuds Ati Alipour”

  • The Crimson: “Not All Disruptions Are Created Equal” — editorial by The Crimson Editorial Board

  • The Crimson: “Dissent: You Can’t Have a Strike and Ignore It Too” — dissent by Adam Chiocco (AB ‘27) and Zakiriya Gladney (AB ‘27)

  • The Crimson: “Hostage-Taking Isn’t a Negotiation Tactic” — op-ed by Michael Isayan (AB ‘29)

  • The Crimson: “At Harvard, Communication Should Be on the Syllabus” — op-ed by Ally Hwang (AB ‘29)

  • The Crimson: “Harvard Admissions Values Identity Over Ideas” — op-ed by Amelia Barnum (AB ‘28)

  • The Crimson: “Great Books for All” — op-ed by Andrew Shlomchik (AB ‘29)

  • The Crimson: “Where Are All the Public Servants?” — op-ed by Matthew Tobin (AB ‘27)

More News Beyond Harvard
  • Yale Daily News: “Grade Inflation Policy Delay Relieves Juniors, Worries Sophomores”

  • Yale Daily News: “Policy on Grade Inflation Would Not Kick In Until Fall 2028, Lewis Says”

  • The Dartmouth: “Guarini Will Not Admit Math Ph.D. Cohort This Year”

  • The Dartmouth: “Dartmouth Endowment’s 2026 Return Lags Behind Other Ivies for Second Year”

  • Brown Daily Herald: “Brown Will No Longer Issue CPT Work Authorizations for International Undergraduates”

  • The Tech: “MIT and the GSU Reach Tentative Agreement”

  • Stanford Daily: “Civics Hiring Draws Faculty Disagreement Over Hoover Ties”

  • Stanford Report: “‘What Would Convince You That You’re Wrong?’” — on “Disagree with a Professor,” which invites students to take up provocative ideas with Stanford faculty in an informal, low-stakes setting 

  • Duke Chronicle: “Why Might Dan Ariely Still Be at Duke? Tenure and a Lengthy Research Misconduct Investigatory Process” — feat. Duke professor Dan Ariely, who co-authored a 2012 study on dishonesty with ex-HBS professor Francesca Gino that was later retracted over fabricated data 

  • Chronicle of Higher Education: “John Sailer Waged War Against DEI. He Thinks It Will Roar Back.” — feat. Manhattan Institute senior fellow John Sailer

  • Chronicle of Higher Education: “The Number of Undergrads With Disabilities Is Growing. These Were the Changes at Each College.”

  • Chronicle of Higher Education: “The Professors Ditching Tech to Protect Learning” 

  • Jewish Insider: “Former Trump Official Josh Gruenbaum Says Elite College Presidents Privately Welcomed Admin Pressure”

  • Brandeis Center: “Brandeis Center Files Federal Lawsuit, Moves to Intervene to Expose Billions in Foreign Funding to U.S. Universities”

  • Dartmouth President’s LinkedIn: “Preparing for Pressure Is Part of an Education” — by Dartmouth President Sian Beilock

  • National Association of Scholars: “The Business of Academic Access” — report by NAS Senior Fellow for International Affairs & Academic Integrity Lilla Nóra Kiss 

  • Education Next: “Judging Education Reactions and Overreactions to the Big Blue Wave” — by Frederick Hess (EdM ‘90, AM ‘96, PhD ‘97)

  • Chronicle of Higher Education: “Why the Left Should Defend Civics Centers” — by University of Utah professor Hollis Robbins 

  • Anecdotal Value: “You Are Protesting the Wrong Technology, People!” — by University of Utah professor Hollis Robbins 

  • Chronicle of Higher Education: “‘Punished for My Deviations’: A gender-studies professor hits back at her field” — interview with Ohio State women’s, gender, and sexuality studies professor emerita Cynthia Burack

  • Chronicle of Higher Education: “Anthropology’s Forever War With Itself” — by University of Alabama legal anthropologist and law professor Deepa Das Acevedo

  • The Dartmouth: “Davis: What Happened to Dartmouth Conservatives?” — op-ed by Dartmouth sophomore Becca Davis